- Just Like It Was Before
- Donny Novitski
- I Know a Guy
- Ain't We Proud
- Proud Riff
- Who I Was
- Counterpoint / Pie Jesu
- Just Like It Was Before (Reprise)
- First Steps First
- Breathe
- You Deserve It
- Dwight Anson & Jean Ann
- Love Will Come and Find Me Again
- Right This Way
- Nobody
- The Boys Are Back
- I Got a Theory
- Everything Happens
- Welcome Home
- A Band in New York City
- This Is Life
- This Is Life (Reprise)
- Welcome Home (Finale)
- Epilogue
